Numei Wamah, Deekermue Paye, Norazlina Noordin, Faiz Ahmad, James S Dolo, Quaqua S Mulbah, Joseph Ndebeh, Baba Drammeh, Abdul Aziz Sanyang
Pages: 343-349 | 455 Views 120 Downloads
Keywords: Gamma irradiation, Radiosensitivity, Oryza sativa, Mutation breeding, Suakoko-8
Rice underpins food security in Liberia and is both the main staple and a cultural mainstay for most of the population. However, domestic production has not kept pace with rising consumption demand, leaving the country heavily dependent on imported rice thereby underscoring the need to raise local rice production (Africa Rice Center et al., 2025) [1]. Varietal improvement is one route to closing this gap, and it can proceed through conventional hybridization, marker-assisted selection, or the induction of mutations with physical or chemical mutagens. Gamma radiation is among the most widely used physical mutagens in crop mutation breeding, since it produces heritable variation at both the nucleotide and chromosomal levels (Bharath et al., 2024; Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [2, 3]. Many crop varieties released officially around the world originated from induced mutation (Rasmussen et al., 2024) [4], and gamma-ray programs continue to be useful for creating variability in crops with a narrow gene pool, such as many elite rice cultivars (Elsherbiny et al., 2024) [5].
Liberia’s rice sub-sector depends on a limited set of local landraces and internationally bred improved lines, and research on locally adapted, high-yielding varieties remains limited (Africa Rice Center et al., 2025) [1]. Local genotypes are valuable sources of adaptive genes (Lazaridi et al., 2024) [6] and suit farmers’ agro-ecologies and taste preferences, but they tend to be tall, lodging-prone and comparatively low yielding, a pattern also reported for local cultivars in other tropical regions (Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [3]. Hybridization is a slow way to correct these deficiencies and is further limited by modest research capacity and infrastructure (Africa Rice Center et al., 2025) [1]. Induced mutagenesis is faster because defects can be fixed within adapted, farmer-preferred backgrounds while the identity of the variety is preserved (Elsherbiny et al., 2024; Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [5, 3]. This approach, however, cannot be pursued responsibly without first understanding how the target genotypes respond to the mutagen. Without genotype-specific data, researchers must rely on doses established for genotypes from other countries and ecologies, which risks either an ineffective treatment or excessive mortality in the treated population.
Radiosensitivity, the way a genotype responds to increasing mutagen doses, must therefore be determined first in any induced-mutation program (Almendral Vera Cruz et al., 2025; Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [7, 3]. Tolerance varies between genotypes and is influenced by seed moisture content, seed vigor and genotype-specific DNA repair efficiency (Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [3]. Radiosensitivity is usually measured with dose response bioassays that record germination percentage, seedling height, root length, survival and fertility over a range of doses; the results are then used to derive reference points such as the lethal dose 50 (LD50) and the reduction dose 50 (RD50) (Almendral Vera Cruz et al., 2025; Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [3]. In rice, low-to-moderate doses usually maintain or stimulate growth, while doses of 400 gray (Gy) and above generally impair it (Elsherbiny et al., 2024) [5], and radiosensitivity has been established for rice varieties in Kenya (Wagatua et al., 2022) [8]. Comparable data are not yet available for the rice genotypes cultivated in Liberia, which have been characterized mainly for agronomic performance rather than for mutagen response.
This study therefore aimed to generate genotype-specific radiosensitivity data as a foundation for a later mutation-breeding program targeting improved yield potential, lodging resistance and tolerance to prevalent local stresses. Specifically, it determined the radiosensitivity of two locally adapted lowland rice varieties, Suakoko-8 Red and Suakoko-8 White, to gamma radiation to establish suitable doses for mutation induction.
The experiment was conducted at the Malaysian Nuclear Agency, Malaysia. Seeds were irradiated at the irradiation facility of the Agrotechnology and Biosciences Division (Acute Biobeam Gamma Cell Facility), and seedlings were grown at the Plant Physiology Laboratory. A completely randomized design with two replications was used to ensure unbiased allocation of treatments, with six gamma doses applied to each of the two varieties.
Two locally adapted lowland rice varieties, Suakoko-8 Red and Suakoko-8 White, were obtained from the Central Agricultural Research Institute (CARI), Liberia. The average moisture content of the seeds before irradiation was 11.6%.
The study followed the FAO/IAEA radiosensitivity protocol (FAO/IAEA, 2024) [9] with some modifications. Six gamma-ray doses (0, 100, 200, 300, 400 and 600 Gy), adapted from Lee et al. (2019) [10] were applied; the 0 Gy treatment served as the control. For each variety, approximately 60 seeds were randomly drawn from the seed lot and placed in a labeled brown paper envelope for each dose, and the envelopes were placed in a Petri dish on the irradiator. Irradiation was carried out using a Gamma Cell BioBeam GM 8000 cesium-137 irradiator at a dose rate of 8.6 Gy/min.
Immediately after irradiation, the seeds were soaked for 24 hours in a solution of 3 g of active Ancom Thiram 80 fungicide in 5 ml of water (0.6 g/ml), transferred to Petri dishes and incubated in a growth chamber. The seeds were then placed on moist paper using the growing-rack (sandwich blotter) technique in a germination chamber at the Plant Physiology Laboratory, with the temperature maintained between 21 and 32 °C, relative humidity (RH) at 80–95%, and a controlled photoperiod provided by LED fluorescent lighting.
Data were collected on germination percentage, seedling emergence, seedling survival and seedling height, following Gupta et al. (2021) [11]. Germination was recorded when the primary root (radicle) had emerged, and the percentage was taken at 7 days after sowing (DAS). Seedling emergence, scored as the presence of a shoot, was recorded as a rate (proportion of seedlings per replicate) at 7 and 14 DAS, and seedling survival was recorded at 14 DAS. Seedling height (cm) was measured at 7 and 14 DAS. The LD50 was calculated from emergence and survival rates, whereas the median reduction dose (RD50) and the reduction dose 30 (RD30; Lee et al., 2019) [10] were calculated from seedling height at 14 DAS, following Gupta et al. (2021) [11].
Data were entered in Microsoft Excel 2024. Analysis of variance was performed in R software version 4.6.2, followed by mean separation using Tukey’s honestly significant difference (HSD) test at P < 0.05 where the effect was significant. Germination percentage, emergence rate, survival rate and seedling height were fitted to regression models in CurveExpert Professional version 2.7.3, with gamma dose as the independent variable. Emergence and survival were expressed as a percentage of the 0 Gy rate, and seedling height at 14 DAS as a percentage of the 0 Gy control, before model fitting. Graphs were prepared in GraphPad Prism 9.3.1.
Analysis of variance showed that gamma dose had no significant effect on germination percentage, whereas the two varieties differed significantly (Table 1). Suakoko-8 White had the higher germination (90%, group a) and Suakoko-8 Red the lower (75%, group b; Figure 1). The absence of a dose effect agrees with Wagatua et al. (2022) [8], who found no significant effect of gamma irradiation on germination in four Kenyan rice varieties.

Gamma dose had no significant effect on the rate of seedling emergence in either variety at 7 or 14 DAS (Table 2), and no dose differed from the control (all means share the letter a; Table 3; Figure 2). The lowest rates were recorded for Suakoko-8 White at 400 Gy at 14 DAS (0.50) and for Suakoko-8 Red at 400 Gy at 7 DAS and 600 Gy at 14 DAS (0.60). These values did not follow a dose trend, and Suakoko-8 Red at 600 Gy at 7 DAS (1.00) equaled the control, which illustrates the scatter in the data.
| Source of variation | Df | Mean square | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dose | 5 | 150.00 | ns |
| Variety | 1 | 1350.00 | * |
| Residual | 17 | 173.53 |
* significant at P < 0.05; ns, not significant. Source: Authors, 2026.
DAS, days after sowing; ns, not significant. Source: Authors, 2026.
Red, Suakoko-8 Red; White, Suakoko-8 White. Means within a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (Tukey HSD, P < 0.05). Source: Authors, 2026.
| Source of variation | Df | Suakoko-8 Red | Suakoko-8 White |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dose | 5 | 0.0390 ns | 0.0350 ns |
| Replicate | 1 | 0.0817 ns | 0.0017 ns |
| DAS | 1 | 0.0150 ns | 0.0150 ns |
| Residual | 16 | 0.0483 | 0.0271 |

Wagatua et al. (2022) [8] reported significant reductions in emergence from 400 Gy, whereas none was detected here up to 600 Gy. Two explanations are likely. First, each cell of the design contained only ten seedlings (two replicates of five), which limits the power to detect moderate effects. Second, emergence was scored as the presence of a shoot, so a seedling that emerged but then stopped growing was still counted. The height data support this: seedlings at 600 Gy were present but only about 0.4 cm tall (Table 5). Emergence alone therefore underestimates damage at high doses, and shoot growth is the more sensitive indicator. Dose-dependent declines in germination and survival, with no seedlings surviving beyond 600 Gy, were recently reported for the Philippine variety NSIC Rc 218 (Almendral Vera Cruz et al., 2025) [7].
| Gamma dose (Gy) | Red, 7 DAS | Red, 14 DAS | White, 7 DAS | White, 14 DAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 1.0000a | 0.9000a | 0.9000a | 0.9000a |
| 100 | 0.7000a | 0.7000a | 0.9000a | 1.0000a |
| 200 | 0.7000a | 0.7000a | 0.9000a | 0.9000a |
| 300 | 0.8000a | 0.8000a | 0.9000a | 1.0000a |
| 400 | 0.6000a | 0.8000a | 0.9000a | 0.5000a |
| 600 | 1.0000a | 0.6000a | 0.9000a | 0.8000a |
When emergence (7 DAS) and survival (14 DAS) were analyzed together, dose, replicate and DAS were all non-significant in both varieties (Table 2). Emergence and survival therefore did not differ significantly, and gamma irradiation up to 600 Gy did not significantly reduce survival to 14 DAS (Table 3). Survival at 14 DAS ranged from 0.60 to 0.90 in Suakoko-8 Red and from 0.50 to 1.00 in Suakoko-8 White, with the lowest values for Suakoko-8 Red at 600 Gy (0.60) and Suakoko-8 White at 400 Gy (0.50). In contrast, Wagatua et al. (2022) [8] found that survival fell significantly from 300 to 400 Gy in their most sensitive varieties. The absence of a survival effect here is most likely explained by the short 14-day scoring window, the small number of seedlings per replicate and the proxy definition used for survival. Survival measured over a longer period, or defined by seedling vigor, would be more informative.
Dose, DAS and replicate effects on seedling height were assessed for each variety (Table 4). Dose and DAS were highly significant in both varieties (P < 0.001), and replicate was significant for Suakoko-8 Red only (P < 0.05). Seedlings were taller at 14 DAS than at 7 DAS, as expected for growth over time. Residual degrees of freedom differ between varieties because seedlings without a shoot measurement were excluded. Mean separation showed that height was significantly reduced from 300 Gy in both varieties and at both ages (Table 5). At 14 DAS, seedlings radiated with 300 Gy reached about two-thirds of the control height (Suakoko-8 Red, 12.93 cm against 19.37 cm; Suakoko-8 White, 13.14 cm against 20.07 cm). Reduction was severe at 400 Gy and almost complete at 600 Gy (about 0.4 cm in both varieties). The two varieties differed at 400 Gy: Suakoko-8 Red kept 9.04 cm (about 47% of the control) at 14 DAS, whereas Suakoko-8 White fell to 1.20 cm (about 6%), placing it in the same statistical group as 600 Gy.
| Variety | Source of variation | Df | Mean square |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suakoko-8 Red | Dose | 5 | 477.84 *** |
| Replicate | 1 | 49.54 * | |
| DAS | 1 | 1461.56 *** | |
| Residual | 85 | 9.70 | |
| Suakoko-8 White | Dose | 5 | 864.15 *** |
| Replicate | 1 | 8.73 ns | |
| DAS | 1 | 845.35 *** | |
| Residual | 97 | 12.68 |
*** significant at P < 0.001; * significant at P < 0.05; ns, not significant. Source: Authors, 2026.
Red, Suakoko-8 Red; White, Suakoko-8 White. Means within a column followed by the same letter are not significantly different (Tukey HSD, P < 0.05). Source: Authors, 2026.
| Gamma dose (Gy) | Red, 7 DAS | Red, 14 DAS | White, 7 DAS | White, 14 DAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 7.79a | 19.37a | 11.83a | 20.07a |
| 100 | 9.49a | 21.11a | 11.64a | 20.88a |
| 200 | 8.20a | 18.31a | 10.11a | 19.33a |
| 300 | 4.62b | 12.93b | 7.04b | 13.14b |
| 400 | 2.87bc | 9.04b | 2.21c | 1.20c |
| 600 | 0.47c | 0.45c | 0.41c | 0.40c |
No gamma dose produced a significant gain in height. Nevertheless, the 100 Gy mean was the highest of all doses (Suakoko-8 Red at 7 and 14 DAS, and Suakoko-8 White at 14 DAS), for example 21.11 cm against 19.37 cm for Suakoko-8 Red at 14 DAS. This non-significant tendency is consistent with the low-dose stimulation reported in rice, where doses of 50 to 150 Gy increased seedling survival and height (Wagatua et al., 2022) [8], and where 50 Gy gave the highest germination and increased tillering in the cultivar Mayas (Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [3]. Shoot growth was also slightly stimulated at 100 and 200 Gy in NSIC Rc 218 (Almendral Vera Cruz et al., 2025) [7]. The reduction from 300 Gy matches the threshold above which growth was significantly reduced in earlier rice studies (Harding, 2012; Wagatua et al., 2022) [12, 8]. The growth inhibition seen at high doses is usually explained by oxidative damage from reactive oxygen species, arrest of the cell cycle at the G2/M phase, and disturbed hormone and enzyme function (Kang et al., 2020; Kant et al., 2020; Solim et al., 2021) [13, 14, 15].
Emergence and survival rates were expressed as a percentage of the 0 Gy rate (7 and 14 DAS pooled) and fitted with regression models. Neither variety reached 50% lethality within 0 to 600 Gy, so the LD50 could not be estimated (Table 6); meaning the lethal doses for both varieties may likely be higher than the doses used during the experiment. The pooled rate never fell below about 74% of the control in Suakoko-8 Red or about 78% in Suakoko-8 White. The exponential decay models explained little of the variation (r2 = 0.102 for Suakoko-8 Red and 0.246 for Suakoko-8 White), and extrapolating beyond 600 Gy would not be reliable. On these data, the LD50 of both varieties exceeds 600 Gy, which is higher than the 354 to 556 Gy range reported for four Kenyan rice varieties (Wagatua et al., 2022) [8] and the approximately 295 Gy reported for the Indonesian cultivar Mayas (Herdiyanti et al., 2025) [3]. Direct counts of emerged and surviving seedlings are needed before a reliable LD50 can be given for either variety.
| Variety | LD50 | Regression model |
|---|---|---|
| Suakoko-8 Red | Not reached (> 600 Gy) | Exponential decay, y = 85.907e−0.000193x; r = 0.319, r2 = 0.102, SE = 10.80 |
| Suakoko-8 White | Not reached (> 600 Gy) | Exponential decay, y = 103.755e−0.000248x; r = 0.496, r2 = 0.246, SE = 10.09 |
Source: Authors, 2026.
Observed values stayed between about 74 and 84% of the control in Suakoko-8 Red and between about 78 and 106% in Suakoko-8 White (Figure 3). The only noticeable drop in Suakoko-8 White was at 400 Gy (77.8%). The fitted curves decline gently, reaching 76.5% in Suakoko-8 Red and 89.4% in Suakoko-8 White at 600 Gy, well above the 50% level that defines the LD50, so the LD50 lies beyond the tested range. The low coefficients of determination (0.102 and 0.246) confirm that dose explained little of the variation, which agrees with the non-significant dose effects in Tables 2 and 3. The curves differ from the sigmoidal survival curves of Wagatua et al. (2022) [8], in which survival fell steeply from 300 to 400 Gy in the most sensitive varieties and the LD50 ranged from 354 to 556 Gy. The shallow slopes here probably reflect how survival was scored: a seedling was counted as long as a shoot was recorded, although seedlings at 600 Gy were only about 0.4 cm tall (Table 5) and were unlikely to be viable. In NSIC Rc 218, no seedlings survived beyond 600 Gy and germination and survival fell sharply from 500 Gy (Almendral Vera Cruz et al., 2025) [7]. The LD50 of both Suakoko-8 varieties may therefore be close to 600 Gy, and a viability criterion would be needed to estimate it.

Seedling height at 14 DAS, expressed as a percentage of the 0 Gy control, was fitted with regression models to estimate the doses causing 30% and 50% growth reduction (RD30 and RD50; Table 7). The fits were good for both varieties (r2 = 0.923 for Suakoko-8 Red and 0.997 for Suakoko-8 White). The RD50 was 377.35 Gy for Suakoko-8 Red and 316.90 Gy for Suakoko-8 White, and the RD30 was 266.03 Gy and 294.45 Gy, respectively. The RD50 of Suakoko-8 Red falls within the 335 to 531 Gy range reported for four Kenyan rice varieties (Wagatua et al., 2022) [8] and the 350 to 500 Gy range cited by FAO/IAEA (Spencer-Lopes et al., 2018) [16], whereas that of Suakoko-8 White is slightly lower.
RD50 and RD30, doses causing 50% and 30% reduction in seedling height. Source: Authors, 2026.

The varieties differ in the shape of their response. Suakoko-8 White maintained its height up to about 300 Gy and then collapsed (6% of the control at 400 Gy), so its RD30 and RD50 are only about 22 Gy apart. Suakoko-8 Red declined more gradually, giving a wider interval of about 111 Gy. Both varieties retained 94 to 109% of their control height up to 200 Gy and fell to about two-thirds of it at 300 Gy (66.8% in Suakoko-8 Red, 65.5% in Suakoko-8 White; Figure 4). Beyond 300 Gy the varieties diverged: Suakoko-8 Red declined steadily to 46.7% at 400 Gy, whereas Suakoko-8 White dropped to 6.0%, and both were almost fully inhibited at 600 Gy (2.3 and 2.0%). The sharp transition in Suakoko-8 White means that a small error in delivered dose could change the outcome considerably.
| Variety | RD50 | RD30 | Regression model |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suakoko-8 Red | 377.35 Gy | 266.03 Gy | Linear, y = 117.795 − 0.17966x; r = 0.9606, r2 = 0.9228, SE = 12.55 |
| Suakoko-8 White | 316.90 Gy | 294.45 Gy | Logistic, y = a/(1 + (x/b)c); a = 100.342, b = 316.708, c = 11.474; r = 0.9987, r2 = 0.9973, SE = 3.16 |
The logistic model follows the Suakoko-8 White data closely (r2 = 0.997). The linear model for Suakoko-8 Red predicts 99.8% at 100 Gy, below the observed 109.0%, so it misses the small rise in height at that dose and its RD values should be treated as approximate. This rise is not significant (Table 5) but fits the low-dose stimulation seen in other rice studies (Herdiyanti et al., 2025; Wagatua et al., 2022) [3, 8]. The RD50 of Suakoko-8 White (317 Gy) lies just below the 335 to 531 Gy range reported by Wagatua et al. (2022) [8] and is close to the values for their most sensitive variety, Komboka (335 to 351 Gy). The RD30 of Suakoko-8 Red (266 Gy) is at the lower end of their 267 to 426 Gy range. Overall, Suakoko-8 White behaves as a highly radiosensitive variety with a narrow response window, and Suakoko-8 Red as a moderately sensitive variety with a wider one.
The recommended practice in rice mutation breeding is to select doses between the RD30 and the LD50 (Wagatua et al., 2022) [8]. Because the LD50 was not reached here, the RD30 to RD50 interval provides the practical working range: about 266 to 377 Gy for Suakoko-8 Red and about 294 to 317 Gy for Suakoko-8 White. These ranges should be validated in the M1 generation, ideally with survival and fertility data.
Rice mutation breeding in Liberia has lacked genotype-specific radiosensitivity data, so this study set out to determine the response of two locally adapted varieties, Suakoko-8 Red and Suakoko-8 White, to gamma radiation to establish doses for mutation induction. Gamma irradiation of seeds up to 600 Gy did not significantly affect germination, seedling emergence or survival, so no LD50 could be estimated for either variety (>600 Gy); the varieties differed in germination percentage, with Suakoko-8 White higher than Suakoko-8 Red. Seedling height was a far more sensitive indicator: it was significantly reduced from 300 Gy in both varieties at 7 and 14 DAS and was almost entirely suppressed at 600 Gy, while no dose significantly increased it. The RD50 was 377.35 Gy for Suakoko-8 Red and 316.90 Gy for Suakoko-8 White, and the RD30 was 266.03 Gy and 294.45 Gy, respectively. Doses of about 266 to 377 Gy for Suakoko-8 Red and 294 to 317 Gy for Suakoko-8 White are therefore proposed as the working range for mutation induction. Suakoko-8 White showed a sharper threshold than Suakoko-8 Red, so dose control is more critical for this variety. Because emergence and survival were derived indirectly from shoot records, direct counts of emerged and surviving seedlings, more replicates, and validation in the M1 generation are recommended before these doses are adopted.
This study was conducted as part of a mutation breeding fellowship training at the Malaysian Nuclear Agency, Malaysia, supported by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), Vienna, Austria, through Technical Cooperation Project LIR5004. The authors thank the Director General of the Central Agricultural Research Institute (CARI) and The William V.S Tubman University for authorizing their participation in the training and for providing institutional support. The authors also gratefully acknowledge the Agrotechnology and Biosciences Division, Malaysian Nuclear Agency, for its continued support and facilitation of the smooth implementation of the project.
The authors declare that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Numei Wamah: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Data curation, Formal analysis, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing.
Deekermue Paye: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Data curation, Formal analysis, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing.
Norazlina Noordin: Methodology, Supervision, Writing – review & editing.
Faiz Ahmad: Methodology, Supervision, Writing – review & editing.
Baba Drammeh: Methodology, Investigation & Data curation
Abdul Aziz Sanyang: Methodology, Investigation & Data curation
James S. Dolo: Supervision, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing.
Quaqua S. Mulbah: Supervision, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing.
Joseph Ndebeh: Supervision, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing.
Tebian Abdelrahman: Project administration, Resources, & Supervision.
All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
This research was funded by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) through Technical Cooperation Project LIR5004.