KA Sofi, MH Chesti, SA Mir, RA Mir
Pages: 408-415 | 60 Views 31 Downloads
Keywords: Wheat, Zinc, Boron, Grain yield, Nutrient uptake, Temperate Kashmir
Wheat is a staple cereal across South Asia, and its grain supplies a large share of the daily energy and protein intake of the population. Cereal grains are, however, naturally low in Zn, and the problem becomes more serious when the crop is grown on soils with low plant-available Zn. Zinc deficiency in soils therefore lowers both the yield and the nutritional value of the grain, and the application of Zn fertilizers has been proposed as a rapid way to raise grain Zn while research on Zn-efficient cultivars continues (Cakmak, 2008) [1].
Zinc takes part in a wide range of plant processes, including enzyme activation, carbohydrate metabolism, protein synthesis and the maintenance of membrane integrity. Field studies have shown consistent yield responses of wheat to Zn on deficient soils. Torun et al. (2001) [2] observed that Zn fertilization increased the grain yield of all 25 wheat cultivars they tested, by about 37 to 40% on average, and Seilsepour (2007) [3] related the yield response of wheat to the level of available Zn in soil.
Boron is required for cell wall formation, carbohydrate metabolism, pollen germination and seed development (Vitosh et al., 1997) [4]. It is also involved in the movement of water and nutrients from roots to shoots, and a shortage of B impairs anther development and leads to poor seed set and lower grain yield (Rehm et al., 1998) [5]. Boron deficiency has been reported on many crops and soils worldwide (Shorrocks, 1997) [6]. Wheat is particularly sensitive because of its high B requirement for flower fertilization and grain set, and B application has raised wheat yields on deficient soils (Rashid et al., 2011) [7]. Boron supply has also been linked with higher levels of essential amino acids in wheat protein (Iqtidar et al., 1984) [8] and with improved nutrient uptake by cereals (Singh et al., 1984) [9].
The two micronutrients do not act independently. Their combined supply can influence growth and the concentration of nutrients in plant tissue (Hosseini et al., 2007) [10], and combined application of Zn and B has increased the number of grains per spike and the grain yield of wheat (Ali et al., 2009) [11]. In the temperate Kashmir valley, where wheat is grown as a winter crop, information on the combined response of the crop to Zn and B is limited. The present study was therefore undertaken to assess the effect of Zn and B, applied singly and in combination, on the grain yield of wheat and on the concentration and uptake of Zn and B in grain.
The field experiment was conducted during 2014 and 2015 at the experimental farm of Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Kashmir (SKUAST-K) under the temperate conditions of the Kashmir valley. The soil of the experimental site was an Alfisol of silty clay loam texture. Before sowing, it had pH 6.54, electrical conductivity 0.16 dS m−1, organic carbon 0.76%, available N 283.56 kg ha−1, available P2O5 17.15 kg ha−1 and available K2O 141.45 kg ha−1. The available S, Ca, Mg, Zn, Cu, Fe, Mn and B contents were 10.54, 1810.05, 240.65, 0.82, 1.00, 12.65, 1.54 and 0.67 mg kg−1, respectively.
The experiment comprised 16 treatment combinations of four Zn levels (0, 7.5, 15 and 22 kg Zn ha−1) and four B levels (0, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 kg B ha−1) arranged in a factorial randomized complete block design with three replications. The wheat variety HS-240 was sown during the rabi season at a seed rate of 100 kg ha−1 with a row-to-row spacing of 23 cm in plots measuring 5.0 m × 2.5 m. The recommended dose of 100 kg N, 60 kg P2O5 and 30 kg K2O ha−1 was supplied through urea, diammonium phosphate (DAP) and muriate of potash (MOP). Zinc and B were applied as zinc sulphate and borax, respectively, by broadcasting on the soil surface during field preparation before sowing.
Grain yield was recorded plot-wise at harvest and expressed in q ha−1. Grain samples were oven-dried, ground and analysed for Zn and B. The samples were wet-digested with a di-acid mixture of concentrated nitric acid (HNO3) and perchloric acid (HClO4) in the ratio 9:3, and the digestion was accelerated using a microwave digestion system. Zinc in the digest was determined following the method of Verdier et al. (1957) [12], and B was determined by the azomethine-H spectrophotometric (colorimetric) method described by Gaines et al. (1979) [13]. Uptake of each nutrient by grain was calculated as follows:
Data for each year and the pooled data over the two years were subjected to analysis of variance appropriate to a factorial randomized complete block design (Gomez et al., 1984) [14]. Treatment means were compared using critical difference (CD) values at the 5% level of probability.
Grain yield increased significantly with Zn application up to 15 kg Zn ha−1 (Table 1; Fig. 1a). On a pooled basis, mean grain yield rose from 31.36 q ha−1 without Zn to 33.69, 35.77 and 34.04 q ha−1 with 7.5, 15 and 22 kg Zn ha−1, which corresponded to increases of 7.43, 14.06 and 8.55% over the control. The yield at 15 kg Zn ha−1 was significantly higher than that at 22 kg Zn ha−1, which indicated that the Zn requirement of the crop was met at the intermediate rate. The response was attributed to the role of Zn in enzyme activity, carbohydrate metabolism and protein synthesis, which supported better growth and grain filling. Positive yield responses of wheat to Zn were also reported by Torun et al. (2001) [2], El-Majid et al. (2000) [15] and Seilsepour (2007) [3].
Among the B levels (Fig. 1b), 1.5 kg B ha−1 produced the highest mean grain yield (34.88 q ha−1), which was significantly higher than that at all other levels. Grain yield increased by 4.11, 9.44 and 3.39% over the control with 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 kg B ha−1, respectively. The lower yield at 2.0 kg B ha−1 showed that the range between adequate and excess B supply was narrow. Improved pollen viability, seed set and grain formation under adequate B supply probably accounted for the yield gain (Rehm et al., 1998; Shorrocks, 1997) [5, 6]. Rashid et al. (2011) [7] likewise recorded higher wheat yields with B application on B-deficient soils.
The Zn × B interaction for grain yield was significant (Fig. 1c). Pooled grain yield ranged from 29.47 q ha−1 in the control to 36.02 q ha−1 under Zn15B1.5, an increase of 22.23%. Combinations involving the highest rates of the two nutrients gave lower yields, the lowest among them being 30.73 q ha−1 under Zn22B2.0. The higher yield under the combined application of moderate rates pointed to a complementary effect of the two nutrients. Ali et al. (2009) [11] found that combined Zn and B application raised the number of grains per spike and the grain yield of wheat, and yield gains with combined micronutrient application were also reported by Arif et al. (2006) [16], Islam et al. (1999) [17] and Asad et al. (2000) [18].


Grain Zn concentration increased significantly with Zn application up to 15 kg Zn ha−1 (Table 2; Fig. 2a). The pooled value rose from 42.15 mg kg−1 in the control to 50.00 mg kg−1 at 15 kg Zn ha−1, an increase of 18.62%, and then declined significantly to 48.51 mg kg−1 at 22 kg Zn ha−1. The decline at the highest rate coincided with the lower grain yield at that rate and may reflect a nutrient imbalance at the higher dose; this requires further study. Boron application also raised grain Zn (Fig. 2b), from 44.50 mg kg−1 in the control to 49.31 mg kg−1 at 1.5 kg B ha−1 (10.81%), beyond which it fell to 44.70 mg kg−1 at 2.0 kg B ha−1. The positive effect of moderate B on grain Zn suggested a synergistic relationship between the two nutrients.
| Zn levels (kg ha−1) | 2014 | 2015 | Pooled | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | |||||||||||||
| 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | |
| 0 | 30.37 | 31.84 | 33.04 | 32.25 | 33.87 | 29.37 | 30.84 | 32.04 | 31.18 | 30.85 | 29.47 | 31.34 | 32.54 | 31.71 | 31.36 |
| 7.5 | 31.50 | 32.00 | 32.98 | 32.50 | 34.19 | 30.50 | 31.50 | 32.13 | 33.51 | 33.20 | 29.50 | 31.77 | 32.75 | 31.90 | 33.69 |
| 15.0 | 32.00 | 32.56 | 36.52 | 33.50 | 35.63 | 31.75 | 32.06 | 35.52 | 32.23 | 34.32 | 31.75 | 32.12 | 36.02 | 32.36 | 35.77 |
| 22.0 | 32.25 | 32.50 | 35.80 | 31.23 | 32.38 | 31.25 | 31.28 | 34.30 | 30.23 | 33.55 | 31.50 | 31.87 | 35.46 | 30.73 | 34.04 |
| Mean | 32.40 | 33.68 | 35.34 | 33.42 | 31.34 | 32.68 | 34.42 | 32.48 | 31.87 | 33.18 | 34.88 | 32.95 | |||
| CD (p ≤ 0.05) | |||||||||||||||
| Zinc (Zn) | 1.471 | 1.584 | 1.480 | ||||||||||||
| Boron (B) | 1.465 | 1.454 | 1.542 | ||||||||||||
| Zn × B | 2.943 | 3.168 | 2.960 | ||||||||||||
CD: critical difference at p ≤ 0.05; NS: non-significant. Pooled values are over 2014 and 2015.
The Zn × B interaction for grain Zn was non-significant (Fig. 2c), although the highest concentration (55.20 mg kg−1) was recorded under Zn15B1.5 and the lowest (39.84 mg kg−1) in the control. An adequate Zn supply improves root growth and the absorption of Zn from soil and favours its transfer to the developing seed (Grewal et al., 1997; Cakmak, 2008) [19, 1]. Increases in grain Zn with applied Zn were also reported by Dewal et al. (2004) [20], Singh et al. (2004) [21] and Jain (2004) [22].
| Zn levels (kg ha−1) | 2014 | 2015 | Pooled | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | |||||||||||||
| 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | |
| 0 | 40.37 | 42.96 | 43.32 | 43.00 | 42.41 | 39.32 | 41.96 | 43.00 | 42.32 | 41.65 | 39.84 | 42.46 | 43.50 | 42.82 | 42.15 |
| 7.5 | 43.15 | 43.30 | 43.50 | 44.75 | 43.67 | 42.15 | 42.30 | 44.50 | 43.75 | 43.17 | 42.65 | 42.80 | 45.00 | 44.25 | 43.67 |
| 15.0 | 45.26 | 46.23 | 55.30 | 47.67 | 48.62 | 46.85 | 47.23 | 54.23 | 47.63 | 48.99 | 48.50 | 49.73 | 55.20 | 46.46 | 50.00 |
| 22.0 | 45.18 | 45.76 | 53.70 | 46.10 | 47.69 | 45.26 | 47.00 | 52.60 | 44.34 | 47.30 | 47.02 | 48.23 | 53.52 | 45.25 | 48.51 |
| Mean | 43.49 | 44.56 | 48.96 | 45.38 | 45.65 | 44.65 | 48.58 | 44.51 | 44.50 | 45.81 | 49.31 | 44.70 | |||
| CD (p ≤ 0.05) | |||||||||||||||
| Zinc (Zn) | 1.770 | 1.623 | 1.352 | ||||||||||||
| Boron (B) | 1.637 | 1.546 | 1.446 | ||||||||||||
| Zn × B | NS | NS | NS | ||||||||||||
CD: critical difference at p ≤ 0.05; NS: non-significant. Pooled values are over 2014 and 2015.


Grain B concentration varied significantly with both Zn and B (Table 3; Fig. 3a, b). Zinc application increased grain B from 37.61 mg kg−1 in the control to 42.03 mg kg−1 at 15 kg Zn ha−1 (11.75%), after which it decreased significantly to 40.96 mg kg−1 at 22 kg Zn ha−1. Boron application increased grain B from 37.00 mg kg−1 in the control to 43.15 mg kg−1 at 1.5 kg B ha−1 (16.62%), and the value declined to 41.19 mg kg−1 at 2.0 kg B ha−1. The higher grain B with B application reflected the greater availability of B in soil. The Zn × B interaction was non-significant (Fig. 3c); the highest grain B (44.74 mg kg−1) was recorded under Zn15B1.5 and the lowest (33.75 mg kg−1) in the control.
The increase in grain B with Zn observed in this study differed from the findings of Torun et al. (2001) [2], who reported that Zn fertilization did not change shoot B concentration when averaged over 25 wheat cultivars grown on a B-toxic soil. The low B status of the present soil, as against the B-toxic soil in that study, may explain the difference. The relationship between Zn and B in plant tissue is known to depend on the supply of both nutrients (Hosseini et al., 2007) [10].
| Zn levels (kg ha−1) | 2014 | 2015 | Pooled | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | |||||||||||||
| 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | |
| 0 | 33.42 | 37.96 | 40.33 | 39.00 | 37.67 | 32.08 | 34.80 | 39.33 | 37.83 | 36.01 | 33.75 | 36.46 | 41.41 | 38.83 | 37.61 |
| 7.5 | 34.25 | 38.80 | 41.72 | 39.25 | 38.50 | 35.25 | 35.96 | 40.72 | 38.25 | 37.54 | 35.75 | 37.30 | 42.22 | 40.75 | 39.00 |
| 15.0 | 37.26 | 43.50 | 45.70 | 43.50 | 42.49 | 38.26 | 43.50 | 44.24 | 41.70 | 41.92 | 39.70 | 42.33 | 44.74 | 41.35 | 42.03 |
| 22.0 | 35.20 | 43.20 | 44.20 | 42.75 | 41.34 | 36.20 | 42.16 | 42.75 | 41.45 | 40.64 | 38.76 | 39.00 | 44.25 | 41.85 | 40.96 |
| Mean | 35.03 | 40.80 | 43.00 | 41.12 | 35.44 | 39.10 | 41.76 | 39.80 | 37.00 | 39.02 | 43.15 | 41.19 | |||
| CD (p ≤ 0.05) | |||||||||||||||
| Zinc (Zn) | 1.070 | 1.321 | 0.758 | ||||||||||||
| Boron (B) | 1.114 | 1.210 | 1.187 | ||||||||||||
| Zn × B | NS | NS | NS | ||||||||||||
CD: critical difference at p ≤ 0.05; NS: non-significant. Pooled values are over 2014 and 2015.


Zinc application significantly increased Zn uptake by grain (Table 4; Fig. 4a). On a pooled basis, uptake rose from 131.95 g ha−1 in the control to 165.72 g ha−1 at 15 kg Zn ha−1 (25.59%), which was statistically at par with 22 kg Zn ha−1 (157.66 g ha−1). Boron levels did not affect Zn uptake significantly (Fig. 4b), although the highest uptake (169.38 g ha−1) was recorded at 1.5 kg B ha−1. The Zn × B interaction was also non-significant (Fig. 4c), with the maximum uptake of 198.83 g ha−1 under Zn15B1.5. The same trend was observed in both years. Because uptake is the product of grain yield and grain Zn concentration, the increase reflected gains in both. Higher Zn uptake by wheat with Zn application was also reported by Dewal et al. (2004) [20], Parihar et al. (2005) [23] and Jain et al. (2006) [24].
| Zn levels (kg ha−1) | 2014 | 2015 | Pooled | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | |||||||||||||
| 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | |
| 0 | 122.60 | 136.78 | 143.13 | 138.68 | 135.29 | 115.48 | 129.40 | 137.77 | 131.95 | 128.65 | 117.41 | 133.07 | 141.55 | 135.78 | 131.95 |
| 7.5 | 135.92 | 138.16 | 143.46 | 145.44 | 140.74 | 128.56 | 133.25 | 142.98 | 146.61 | 137.85 | 125.82 | 135.98 | 147.38 | 141.16 | 137.57 |
| 15.0 | 144.83 | 150.12 | 201.96 | 159.69 | 164.15 | 148.75 | 151.42 | 192.62 | 153.51 | 161.57 | 153.99 | 159.73 | 198.83 | 150.34 | 165.72 |
| 22.0 | 145.71 | 148.72 | 192.25 | 143.97 | 157.66 | 141.44 | 147.02 | 180.42 | 134.04 | 150.73 | 148.11 | 153.71 | 189.78 | 139.05 | 157.66 |
| Mean | 137.26 | 143.44 | 170.20 | 146.94 | 133.55 | 140.27 | 163.44 | 141.52 | 136.33 | 145.62 | 169.38 | 141.58 | |||
| CD (p ≤ 0.05) | |||||||||||||||
| Zinc (Zn) | 8.52 | 8.54 | 9.19 | ||||||||||||
| Boron (B) | NS | NS | NS | ||||||||||||
| Zn × B | NS | NS | NS | ||||||||||||
CD: critical difference at p ≤ 0.05; NS: non-significant. Pooled values are over 2014 and 2015.


Boron uptake by grain was significantly influenced by both nutrients (Table 5; Fig. 5a, b). Zinc application increased B uptake from 117.81 g ha−1 in the control to 139.23 g ha−1 at 15 kg Zn ha−1 (18.18%), which was at par with 22 kg Zn ha−1 (132.98 g ha−1). Among the B levels, 1.5 kg B ha−1 recorded the highest uptake (147.93 g ha−1), 30.61% more than the control (113.26 g ha−1) and significantly higher than the other levels. The Zn × B interaction was non-significant (Fig. 5c), and the maximum uptake (161.15 g ha−1) was recorded under Zn15B1.5. A similar trend was observed in both years. The higher B uptake followed from the combined increase in grain yield and grain B concentration at these levels.
| Zn levels (kg ha−1) | 2014 | 2015 | Pooled | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | B levels (kg ha−1) | |||||||||||||
| 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | 0 | 1.0 | 1.5 | 2.0 | Mean | |
| 0 | 101.50 | 120.86 | 133.25 | 125.77 | 120.34 | 94.21 | 107.32 | 126.01 | 117.95 | 111.37 | 99.47 | 114.26 | 134.74 | 123.12 | 117.81 |
| 7.5 | 107.89 | 124.16 | 137.60 | 127.56 | 124.30 | 107.51 | 113.27 | 130.83 | 128.17 | 119.94 | 105.46 | 118.50 | 138.92 | 130.00 | 123.22 |
| 15.0 | 119.23 | 141.63 | 166.90 | 145.72 | 143.37 | 121.47 | 139.46 | 157.14 | 134.40 | 138.11 | 126.04 | 135.96 | 161.15 | 133.80 | 139.23 |
| 22.0 | 113.52 | 140.40 | 158.23 | 133.50 | 136.41 | 113.12 | 131.87 | 146.63 | 125.30 | 129.23 | 122.09 | 124.29 | 156.91 | 128.60 | 132.98 |
| Mean | 110.53 | 131.76 | 148.99 | 133.13 | 109.07 | 122.98 | 140.15 | 126.45 | 113.26 | 123.25 | 147.93 | 128.88 | |||
| CD (p ≤ 0.05) | |||||||||||||||
| Zinc (Zn) | 8.72 | 8.24 | 6.70 | ||||||||||||
| Boron (B) | 8.25 | 8.43 | 7.15 | ||||||||||||
| Zn × B | NS | NS | NS | ||||||||||||
CD: critical difference at p ≤ 0.05; NS: non-significant. Pooled values are over 2014 and 2015.


Soil application of Zn and B significantly improved the grain yield of wheat and the concentration and uptake of both nutrients in grain under the temperate conditions of Kashmir. Grain yield and grain Zn and B concentrations were highest at 15 kg Zn ha−1 and 1.5 kg B ha−1 and declined at the higher rates of either nutrient. The combination of 15 kg Zn ha−1 with 1.5 kg B ha−1 gave the highest grain yield (36.02 q ha−1) together with the highest grain Zn and B concentrations. This combination can be suggested for wheat on similar soils of the valley. Multi-location trials are needed before a general recommendation is made for the different agro-climatic zones of the region.
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.