Sayali V Nannaware, PR Panchbhai, RM Wadaskar, BN Chaudhari, Tini Pillai, HB Goramnagar
Pages: 423-426 | 62 Views 32 Downloads
Keywords: Aphis gossypii, azadirachtin, biopesticides, Lecanicillium lecanii, neem oil, okra
Okra [Abelmoschus esculentus (L.) Moench] is infested by more than seventy insect species (Rao et al., 2003) [1]. Aphids, jassids and whiteflies make up the main sap-sucking complex of the crop, and together with the shoot and fruit borers they are its principal pests (Meena et al., 2005) [2]. The cotton aphid, Aphis gossypii Glover, multiplies in colonies on tender shoots and the underside of leaves; nymphs and adults withdraw sap, so heavily infested plants lose vigour, and the honeydew they excrete favours sooty mould on the foliage. Repeated insecticide sprays against such pests have encouraged resistance, resurgence and residues, which has turned attention towards biopesticides.
Evidence for botanical and fungal control of aphids on okra comes largely from single-product trials. Neem-based formulations rotated with synthetic insecticides kept jassid and aphid numbers down (Bagade et al., 2010) [3]. In organically grown okra, a neem formulation (3.5%) held aphids at 1.67–3.17 per three leaves, while L. lecanii at 2.5 g l−1 gave 2.53–6.67 (Naik et al., 2012) [4]. Azadirachtin lowered aphid infestation progressively over successive sprays, with a 61.55% reduction after the fifth application (Kaushal et al., 2021) [5], and L. lecanii used alone managed okra aphids while sparing ladybird beetles (Bade et al., 2017) [6]. A combination of Verticillium lecanii and M. anisopliae also suppressed aphids on okra (Palthiya, 2014) [7]. Bioassays likewise show that A. gossypii is susceptible to entomopathogens: L. lecanii and B. bassiana at 0.25% caused complete mortality (Karthikeyan et al., 2011) [8], an oil formulation of L. lecanii killed all aphids in vitro (Naik et al., 2009) [9], V. lecanii was effective against the pest on cucumber under protected cultivation (Pinna, 1992) [10], and a virulent B. bassiana isolate at 1 × 108 conidia ml−1 killed 58–91% of cowpea aphids (Ekesi et al., 2000) [11]. Little is known, however, about a programme in which a botanical is sprayed first, a single fungus second and a multi-fungus consortium last. The present study tested six such programmes against A. gossypii on okra.
The trial was laid out at the insectary field of the Entomology Section, College of Agriculture, Nagpur (21°10′ N, 79°19′ E; 321.26 m above mean sea level) in the 2025 kharif season. Okra cultivar NOL-303 (Julie) was dibbled on 15 July 2025 at a spacing of 60 cm between rows and 45 cm between plants. Net plots measured 2.4 m × 3.1 m, fertiliser was applied at 100:50:50 kg N:P:K ha−1, and all other operations followed standard recommendations. Seven modules (Table 1) were allotted in a randomised block design with three replications. Each spray liquid was prepared in the field just before use, and sprays were given at 30, 40 and 50 days after sowing (DAS), i.e. on 14 August, 24 August and 3 September 2025; the control plots received plain water. Marketable fruits were harvested plot-wise and yield was converted to q ha−1. Yield and treatment-cost data from the same trial were used to work out net incremental benefit and the incremental cost-benefit ratio (ICBR) at an okra price of Rs. 4,000 q−1. Treatment cost comprised the price of the biopesticides and spraying labour, which came to Rs. 7,546 ha−1 for the azadirachtin modules and Rs. 13,300 ha−1 for the neem oil modules. The value of the additional yield over the control was calculated at the same price; deducting treatment cost from it gave the net incremental benefit, and ICBR was expressed as treatment cost: net incremental benefit.
Nymphs and adults of aphid were counted on three leaves per plant (one each from the upper, middle and lower canopy) on five tagged plants in every plot. Counts were taken one day before the first spray (1 DBS) and nine days after the first, second and third sprays (9 DAFS, 9 DASS and 9 DATS). The cumulative value for a plot was the mean of the three post-spray counts. Before analysis of variance the counts were transformed as , and treatment means were compared using SE(m)± and critical difference (CD) at the 5% level. Reduction over control (%) was calculated from untransformed means as , where C is the control mean and T the treatment mean.
Before the first spray, aphid density in the plots ranged from 3.76 to 4.13 per leaf and did not differ significantly, so the infestation was uniform (Table 2). Nine days after the first spray (9 DAFS), every treated plot held fewer aphids than the control (5.60 per leaf). M3 had the fewest (2.47 per leaf), followed by M2 (2.53), M1 (2.60), M6 (2.73), M5 (2.80) and M4 (2.87), and these six modules did not differ significantly from one another. After the second spray the control rose to 6.00 per leaf, whereas M3 (1.93), M6 (2.11), M2 (2.20), M5 (2.27), M1 (2.33) and M4 (2.40) stayed significantly lower. Nine days after the third spray (9 DATS), M3 again recorded the lowest count (1.67), followed by M6 (1.80), M2 (1.93), M5 (2.00), M1 (2.20) and M4 (2.27), against 7.60 in the control.
Pooled over the three sprays, M3 had the lowest density (2.02 per leaf), followed by M6 (2.21), M2 (2.22), M5 (2.36), M1 (2.38) and M4 (2.51), compared with 6.40 in the control. All six biopesticide modules were significantly better than the control (CD at 5% = 0.22), but none differed significantly from another. Reduction over control (Fig 1) was highest in M3 (68.44%), followed by M6 (65.47%) and M2 (65.31%), and lowest in M4 (60.78%). It increased with each successive spray, from 48.75–55.89% at 9 DAFS to 70.13–78.03% at 9 DATS.
Marketable fruit yield and the economics of the complete sequential modules are given in Table 3. M3 gave the highest yield (61.96 q ha−1), followed by M6 (59.54 q ha−1), while the control yielded 24.73 q ha−1. With a yield CD of 9.00 q ha−1 at 5%, M3 was statistically at par with M6, M2 (55.78 q ha−1) and M5 (53.36 q ha−1). M3 also recorded the highest net incremental benefit (Rs. 1,41,374 ha−1) and ICBR (1:18.73), whereas M4 had the lowest ICBR (1:5.71). Because the modules also acted on other sucking pests, these are module-level outcomes and cannot be attributed to aphid suppression alone.
The lower aphid counts in every sprayed plot after the first spray show that opening the schedule with a botanical checked the early growth of colonies. Azadirachtin and neem oil act as antifeedants and growth disruptors, so nymphs feed poorly and moult abnormally, and colonies expand slowly. Comparable suppression of okra aphids by neem-based products and azadirachtin has been recorded earlier (Bagade et al., 2010; Naik et al., 2012; Kaushal et al., 2021) [3, 4, 5]. At 9 DAFS the azadirachtin modules (M1–M3; 2.47–2.60 aphids leaf−1) were numerically ahead of the neem oil modules (M4–M6; 2.73–2.87 aphids leaf−1), but the difference was not significant. Since botanicals and fungal agents have been found compatible against sucking pests (Halder et al., 2021) [12], following a botanical with fungal sprays is also biologically sound.
From the second spray onward the modules containing L. lecanii (M3 and M6) carried the fewest aphids, and they were also the two best on the pooled mean. Aphids have a thin, soft cuticle that germinating conidia can penetrate readily, which probably explains the strong showing of this fungus. The result agrees with the complete mortality obtained in vitro with an L. lecanii oil formulation (Naik et al., 2009) [9], with the control of okra aphids by L. lecanii alone and its safety to ladybird beetles (Bade et al., 2017) [6], and with the effect of V. lecanii reported by (Palthiya) [7]. Even so, the B. bassiana (M2, M5) and M. anisopliae (M1, M4) modules were also significantly better than the control and statistically at par with M3, so all three fungi seem useful after a botanical. The ranking of fungi is not constant across studies: in Bt cotton, M. anisopliae gave fewer aphids than L. lecanii and B. bassiana (Nazir, 2008) [13], whereas the M. anisopliae modules ranked last here, which suggests that performance depends on crop, isolate, dose and formulation. The fall in aphid numbers continued through the third spray, which carried the consortium, and reduction over control reached 70.13–78.03% at 9 DATS. This rise reflects the accumulated effect of all three sprays together with the growth of the control population (5.60 to 7.60 aphids leaf−1), so the separate contribution of the consortium cannot be judged from this design.
Yield and economics assess the modules as a whole. M3 gave the highest yield and ICBR, and its yield was statistically at par with M2, M5 and M6. The cheaper azadirachtin schedules (Rs. 7,546 ha−1 against Rs. 13,300 ha−1 for neem oil) raised ICBR: M3 and M6 had statistically similar yields, yet their ICBR values were 1:18.73 and 1:9.47, respectively. Azadirachtin was likewise profitable on okra in earlier work (yield 59.63 q ha−1; ICBR 1:5.72) (Kaushal et al., 2021) [5], and L. lecanii gave the best yield and ICBR in Bt cotton (Raghunandan et al., 2018) [14]. As the modules also acted on other sucking pests, these figures show combined module performance, and the present trial does not isolate the part played by aphid suppression.
| Module | Spray 1 (30 DAS) | Spray 2 (40 DAS) | Spray 3 (50 DAS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| M1 | Azadirachtin 1.00% EC (2 ml l−1) | Metarhizium anisopliae 1.15% WP, 1 × 108 CFU g−1 (5 g l−1) | Bioinoculant (Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Lecanicillium lecanii) 2 × 108 CFU ml−1 (10 ml l−1) |
| M2 | Azadirachtin 1.00% EC (2 ml l−1) | Beauveria bassiana 1.15% WP, 1 × 108 CFU g−1 (5 g l−1) | Bioinoculant (Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Lecanicillium lecanii) 2 × 108 CFU ml−1 (10 ml l−1) |
| M3 | Azadirachtin 1.00% EC (2 ml l−1) | Lecanicillium lecanii 1.15% WP, 2 × 108 CFU g−1 (5 g l−1) | Bioinoculant (Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Lecanicillium lecanii) 2 × 108 CFU ml−1 (10 ml l−1) |
| M4 | Neem oil (10 ml l−1) | Metarhizium anisopliae 1.15% WP, 1 × 108 CFU g−1 (5 g l−1) | Bioinoculant (Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Lecanicillium lecanii) 2 × 108 CFU ml−1 (10 ml l−1) |
| M5 | Neem oil (10 ml l−1) | Beauveria bassiana 1.15% WP, 1 × 108 CFU g−1 (5 g l−1) | Bioinoculant (Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Lecanicillium lecanii) 2 × 108 CFU ml−1 (10 ml l−1) |
| M6 | Neem oil (10 ml l−1) | Lecanicillium lecanii 1.15% WP, 2 × 108 CFU g−1 (5 g l−1) | Bioinoculant (Metarhizium anisopliae, Beauveria bassiana, Lecanicillium lecanii) 2 × 108 CFU ml−1 (10 ml l−1) |
| M7 (control) | Water spray |
DAS: days after sowing; EC: emulsifiable concentrate; WP: wettable powder; CFU: colony-forming units.
| Module | 1 DBS | 9 DAFS | 9 DASS | 9 DATS | Cumulative |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M1 | 3.87 (2.07) | 2.60 (1.74) | 2.33 (1.67) | 2.20 (1.64) | 2.38 (1.69) |
| M2 | 3.91 (2.09) | 2.53 (1.74) | 2.20 (1.63) | 1.93 (1.55) | 2.22 (1.64) |
| M3 | 4.00 (2.11) | 2.47 (1.71) | 1.93 (1.54) | 1.67 (1.46) | 2.02 (1.58) |
| M4 | 4.13 (2.14) | 2.87 (1.83) | 2.40 (1.69) | 2.27 (1.66) | 2.51 (1.73) |
| M5 | 3.76 (2.06) | 2.80 (1.80) | 2.27 (1.65) | 2.00 (1.57) | 2.36 (1.69) |
| M6 | 4.11 (2.14) | 2.73 (1.79) | 2.11 (1.60) | 1.80 (1.51) | 2.21 (1.64) |
| M7 (control) | 3.91 (2.09) | 5.60 (2.46) | 6.00 (2.55) | 7.60 (2.84) | 6.40 (2.62) |
| F test | NS | Sig. | Sig. | Sig. | Sig. |
| SE(m)± | 0.15 | 0.12 | 0.15 | 0.10 | 0.07 |
| CD at 5% | – | 0.38 | 0.47 | 0.30 | 0.22 |
| CV (%) | 11.98 | 11.25 | 14.73 | 9.37 | 6.70 |
DBS: days before spray; DAFS, DASS, DATS: days after first, second and third spray; NS: non-significant; Sig.: significant at 5%. Data in parentheses are square-root transformed [] values.
| Module | Yield (q ha−1) | Yield increase over control (q ha−1) | Total treatment cost (Rs. ha−1) | Net incremental benefit (Rs. ha−1) | ICBR (cost:benefit) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M1 | 49.59 | 24.86 | 7,546 | 91,894 | 1:12.18 |
| M2 | 55.78 | 31.05 | 7,546 | 1,16,654 | 1:15.46 |
| M3 | 61.96 | 37.23 | 7,546 | 1,41,374 | 1:18.73 |
| M4 | 47.04 | 22.31 | 13,300 | 75,940 | 1:5.71 |
| M5 | 53.36 | 28.63 | 13,300 | 1,01,220 | 1:7.61 |
| M6 | 59.54 | 34.81 | 13,300 | 1,25,940 | 1:9.47 |
| M7 (control) | 24.73 | — | — | — | — |
Note: Okra price = Rs. 4,000 q⁻¹. Gross value of yield increase = yield increase over control × market price; net incremental benefit = gross value of yield increase − total treatment cost. ICBR is expressed as treatment cost: net incremental benefit (1:x). Yield CD at 5% = 9.00 q ha⁻¹.

All six sequential biopesticide programmes reduced aphid density on okra significantly relative to the water-sprayed control. The azadirachtin–L. lecanii–consortium programme (M3) recorded the lowest pooled count (2.02 aphids leaf−1 against 6.40 in the control) and the greatest reduction over control (68.44%); however, the six programmes did not differ significantly from one another. M3 also gave the highest marketable fruit yield (61.96 q ha−1) and ICBR (1:18.73), but these figures reflect the performance of the full modules on the sucking-pest complex and not aphid control alone. Multi-season and multi-location trials are needed to confirm these programmes.
The authors are grateful to the Head of the Entomology Section and the Associate Dean of the College of Agriculture, Nagpur, for providing field and laboratory facilities.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.