Sopan Dinde, Avinash Rathod, SB Borgaonkar, DK Zate, AM Misal
Pages: 433-441 | 69 Views 39 Downloads
Keywords: Heterosis, Okra, Half-diallel, Heterosis, Heterobeltiosis, Useful heterosis
Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus (L.) Moench) is a warm‑season vegetable that has earned a prominent place in kitchen gardens and commercial vegetable systems because of its wide ecological adaptability, year‑round market demand and export potential. It is grown extensively across tropical and subtropical regions, particularly in India, West Africa, Brazil, South‑East Asia, and the southern United States, where it forms an integral part of daily diets and local cuisines (Siemonsma, 1982) [1]. In India, Okra is cultivated during both summer and rainy (kharif) seasons, allowing staggered sowings and continuous pod supply that support household nutrition, local markets and processing chains (FAOSTAT, 2025). Okra is known by different vernacular names across the world, reflecting its cultural embeddedness: “Bhindi” in India, “Lady’s finger” in England, and “Gumbo” in the United States (Lim, 2012) [2]. Immature fresh green pods are usually consumed as a cooked vegetable, prepared in stir‑fries, curries, stews, and mixed dishes, where their characteristic mucilaginous texture helps thicken gravies and soups (Hadiya et al., 2018) [3]. The pods are also pickled, canned or dehydrated, expanding their culinary use and shelf life and creating scope for small‑scale processing enterprises (Gemede et al., 2015) [4]. Traditional uses extend beyond the pods. In parts of India, the root and stem are used to clarify sugarcane juice during jaggery preparation (Gopalakrishnan, 2007) [5]. Seeds have been used as a coffee substitute and as a minor source of edible oil and protein in resource poor settings (Lim, 2012) [2]. Nutritionally, Okra is a low‑calorie vegetable rich in water, dietary fibre, vitamins and minerals, therefore contributes meaningfully to balanced diets. Fresh pods typically contain around 88–90% moisture, 7–8% carbohydrates, about 2% protein and negligible fat, along with small amounts of fibre and mineral matter. Okra provides calcium, phosphorus and iron, and is a good source of vitamin C, vitamin K, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin and folate, making it particularly valuable in regions where animal‑source foods are scarce or unaffordable (Sugani Devi et al., 2017) [6]. In Ayurveda and other traditional systems of medicine, Okra is widely recognized for its soothing, protective and diuretic properties. Pod mucilage is used as an edible infusion in conditions associated with irritation or inflammation of the gastrointestinal tract, kidneys and urinary system, including dysentery, diarrhea, ardor urinae and dysuria (Maramag, 2013; Lim, 2012) [7, 2]. Heterosis or hybrid vigour, refers to the superior performance of a hybrid over its parents with respect to one or more traits of economic importance. In practical breeding, heterosis is commonly quantified relative to the mid‑parent value (average heterosis or relative heterosis) and the better parent (heterobeltiosis), and in self‑pollinated or vegetatively propagated crops also in relation to a widely grown commercial check, which is termed standard, useful or economic heterosis (Griffing, 1956; Mather et al., 1971) [8, 9]. For a vegetable crop like Okra, where marketable yield, pod quality and stress tolerance are critical, estimates of standard heterosis against the best available variety or hybrid provide an applied measure of potential gain for farmers and consumers (Reddy et al., 2012). The proposed research study was aimed to study heterosis for yield and its components in Okra, which will help in the identification of a superior parents and hybrids.
The present investigation was undertaken to study “Heterosis for yield and yield component traits in okra (Abelmoschus esculentus (L.) Moench)”. The experiment was carried out at Quality Seed Production Unit, Khanapur A Block, Vasantrao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani, during Summer 2026. The experimental material consisted of six diverse okra genotypes (parents) and fifteen F1 hybrids developed from these parents in a diallel mating system (without reciprocals), along with three checks. These 24 genotypes (6 parents, 15 F1s and 3 check) were evaluated to study heterosis for yield and its components in Okra. The inbred lines of the six parental genotypes were raised in a crossing block at BSP Unit, College of Agriculture, Parbhani, for the purpose of diallel hybridization. Recommended doses of fertilizers and plant protection measures were applied to ensure healthy and uniform plant growth. Observations were recorded for 13 characters: days 50% to flowering, plant height, internodal length, number of nodes/plant, number of branches/plant, number of ridges/fruit, fruit length, fruit diameter, number of fruits/plant, fruit weight, fruit yield/plant, YVMV incidence and fruit and shoot borer severity. Seeds of parents, F1 hybrids and check were sown manually on well prepared ridges and furrows, maintaining the planned spacing and plot size. Standard agronomic practices viz., irrigation, weeding, hoeing, thinning and plant protection were carried out uniformly for all treatments to raise a healthy and uniform crop stand. Five plants were randomly selected from each plot (excluding border plants) and tagged for recording observations. The experiment was laid out in a Randomized Block Design (RBD) with two replications at QSP Unit, Khanapur A Block, VNMKV, Parbhani. The ANOVA was carried out following the standard procedure described by Panse and Sukhatme (1985).
The results are obtained from conducting diallel cross using six parents, fifteen F1 hybrids and three standard checks for thirteen fruit yield and attributing characters. The characters comprised viz; Days to 50% flowering, plant height, internodal length, number of nodes per plant, number of branches per plant, number of ridges per fruit, fruit length, fruit diameter, number of fruits per plant, fruit weight, fruit yield per plant, yellow vein mosaic virus (YVMV) incidence and fruit borer severity. The results are presented and discussed below.
Heterosis was estimated over the mid parent, better parent and three standard checks. Significant negative heterosis was considered desirable for Days to 50% flowering, internodal length, YVMV incidence and fruit borer severity, whereas significant positive heterosis was observed for the remaining characters. The trait-wise results are presented below so that the direction, range and leading combinations are explicit for every character.
Heterosis for days to 50% flowering ranged from -13.29 to 17.86% over the mid parent while -22.68 to 15.19% over the better parent. Three and six hybrids, respectively, exhibited highly significant and negative heterosis over these two parental bases. The hybrid EC-305612 × IC-7472 recorded highly significant and negative heterosis over the mid parent (-13.29%), better parent (-22.68%), Parbhani Kranti (-16.67%), Radhika (-22.68%) and Pusa Sawani (-19.35%). Hence, this hybrid was found superior for earliness. B. Singh et al. (2016) [10] observed useful negative heterosis for earliness in okra, while Venkatesan et al. (2025) [11] also reported early flowering among desirable okra hybrid hybrids.
Heterosis for plant height ranged from -31.27 to 52.98% over the mid parent whereas -38.36 to 37.70% over the better parent. Seven hybrids showed significant positive Average heterosis, whereas three showed significant positive better parent heterosis. The hybrids IC-10256A × EC-305672 displayed highly significant and possible heterosis over the mid parent (52.98%) as well as better parent (37.70%). The hybrid EC-305612 × EC-305672 recorded the highly significant and positive standard heterosis over Parbhani Kranti (36.68%), Radhika (51.80%) and Pusa Sawani (29.51%). Kerure et al. (2019) [12] reported substantial heterotic variation for plant height, and Abdalla and ElKamil (2025) likewise found cross-dependent hybrid vigour for plant height and fruit.
Average heterosis and heterobeltiosis ranged from -21.72 to 42.93% and -34.91 to 35.07%, respectively. Eight hybrids exhibited significant and negative heterosis over the mid parent whereas, eleven hybrids over the better parent. The hybrid EC-305612 × IC-3769 was found desirable for internodal length over the mid parent (-21.72%), better parent (-34.91%), Parbhani Kranti (-34.91%), Radhika2 (-25.98%) and Radhika3 (-27.61%). El-Sherbeny et al. (2018) [13] observed marked heterotic responses for internodal length under different environments and Akotkar et al. (2025b) [14] reported useful heterosis for component traits associated with plant compactness.
Average heterosis for number of nodes per plant ranged from -11.25 to 39.94% over the mid parent whereas, it ranged from -18.66 to 32.14% over the better parent. Nine and eight hybrids, respectively, showed significant positive average heterosis and heterobeltiosis for number of nodes per plant. The hybrid IC-10256A × EC-305672 recorded high significance over the mid parent (39.94%) and better parent (32.14%). The hybrid EC-305612 × EC-305672 recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over Parbhani Kranti (23.32%), Radhika (34.53%) and Pusa Sawani (27.88%) respectively. Verma et al. (2020) [15] reported favourable hybrid vigour for the number of nodes and other yield components in intraspecific okra hybrids.
Average heterosis ranged from -22.43 to 26.11%, whereas heterobeltiosis ranged from 32.06 to 16.97%. Eleven hybrids displayed significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent whereas, five hybrids recorded significant and positive heterosis over the better parent. The hybrid IC-10256A × EC-305672 exhibited highly significant and possible heterosis over the mid parent (26.11%). Whereas EC-305612 × EC-305672 exhibited highly significant and possible heterosis over the better parent (16.97%) as well as over three checks (20.60%, 25.06% and 23.09%) respectively. Kerure et al. (2019) [12] observed positive heterosis for branches per plant in selected crosses, linking improved branching with greater yield potential.
Heterosis for number of ridges per fruit over the mid parent ranged from -6.94 to 33.27% whereas over the better parent from -13.42 to 27.68%. Twelve hybrids recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent and ten hybrids over the better parent respectively. The hybrid EC-305612 × IC-7472 displayed highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent (33.27%), better parent (27.68%), Parbhani Kranti (29.88%), Radhika (42.57%) and Pusa Sawani (36.45%) respectively. Yohanna (2023) reported significant heterosis for fruit morphology and yield-attributing characters in okra.
Average heterosis for fruit length ranged from -23.14 to 39.04% and for better parent heterosis from -26.45 to 34.83%. Eleven hybrids recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent whereas ten parents recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the better parent. The hybrid IC-10256A × IC-7472 exhibited highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent (39.04%) and better parent (34.83%), whereas the hybrid IC-10256A × IC-3769 recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over Parbhani Kranti (23.31%), Radhika (15.00%) and Pusa Sawani (10.06%) respectively. Verma et al. (2020) [15] reported useful heterosis for fruit length and quality, while Akotkar et al. (2025b) [14] identified favourable hybrid vigour for fruit dimensions.
Heterosis for fruit diameter ranged from -17.68 to 13.16% over the mid parent whereas -23.12 to 11.21% over the better parent. Eight and four hybrids showed significant positive heterosis over mid parent and better parent respectively. The hybrid EC-305612 × EC-305672 exhibited highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent (13.16%), Parbhani Kranti (13.82%), Radhika (15.87%) and Pusa Sawani (11.85%), while IC-10256A × EC-305672 was best over the better parent (11.21%).N. Singh et al. (2025) [16] found significant heterosis for fruit diameter and related yield-contributing traits in selected okra crosses.
Average heterosis for number of fruits per plant ranged from -29.09 to 34.80% and 33.26 to 24.66% over the better parent. Ten hybrids recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent whereas, seven hybrids recorded highly significant and positive over the better parent. The hybrid IC-10256A × EC-305672 recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent (34.80%) and better parent (24.66%). The hybrid EC-305612 × EC-305672 recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over Parbhani Kranti (26.30%), Radhika (31.16%) and Pusa Sawani (25.93%) respectively. Kerure et al. (2019) [12] and Yadav et al. (2023) [17] reported that favourable heterosis for fruits per plant which contributed to hybrid yield superiority.
Average heterosis for fruit weight ranged from -7.76 to 59.65% whereas, better-parent heterosis ranged from -19.17 to 55.69%. Twelve hybrids displayed highly positive and significant heterosis over the mid parent whereas seven over the better parent. The hybrid IC-4507 × IC-7472 displayed highly positive and significant heterosis over the mid parent (59.65%), better parent (55.69%), Parbhani Kranti (34.87%), Radhika (43.03%) and Pusa Sawani (30.84%) respectively. Verma et al. (2020) [15] observed strong heterosis for fruit weight and quality traits, and Venkatesan et al. (2025) [11] also reported substantial hybrid vigour for fruit weight.
Heterosis for fruit-yield ranged from -25.24 to 35.48% over the mid parent whereas, -27.60 to 22.53% over the better parent. Nine hybrids recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the mid parent whereas four hybrids recorded highly significant and positive heterosis over the better parent. The hybrid IC-10256A × IC-4507 was found highly heterotic over the better parent (22.53%), whereas the hybrid EC-305612 × EC-305672 recorded highly significant and positive standard heterosis over Parbhani Kranti (40.01%), Radhika (45.53%) and Pusa Sawani (34.40%) respectivel. Which recorded 293.250 g yield, with consistent standard heterosis, identified it as the most promising high-yielding cross combination. Kerure et al. (2019) [12], Nanthakumar et al. (2021) [18] and Abdalla and El Kamil (2025) reported commercially useful standard heterosis for fruit yield in selected okra hybrids.
Heterosis for YVMV incidence ranged from -29.46 to 71.58% over the mid parent and from -37.09 to 67.25% over the better parent. Eight hybrids recorded significant and negative heterosis over the mid parent and ten hybrids recorded significant and negative heterosis over the better parent respectively. The hybrid IC-4507 × IC-7472 recorded highly significant and negative heterosis over the mid parent (-29.46%) and better parent (-37.09%), whereas, the hybrid IC-10256A × EC-305672 recorded highly significant and negative heterosis over Parbhani Kranti (-32.08%), Radhika (-42.55%) and Pusa Sawani (-18.18%). Solankey et al. (2016) [19] demonstrated useful heterosis from YVMV resistance sources, while Bharathkumar et al. (2019) [20] and Khade et al. (2020) [21] confirmed a genetic basis for resistance expression.
Heterosis for fruit and shoot borer severity ranged from -52.67 to 40.77% over the mid parent whereas -58.58 to 23.32% over the better parent. Ten hybrids showed significant desirable negative heterosis for fruit and shoot borer severity. The hybrid IC-4507 × IC-7472 recorded highly significant and negative heterosis over the mid parent (-52.67%), better parent (-58.58%), Parbhani Kranti (-61.26%), Radhika (-54.20%) and Pusa Sawani (-38.90%). The hybrid IC-10256A × EC-305672 ranked second for fruit yield and combined low fruit and shoot borer severity. Nagre et al. (2025) [22] and B. Singh et al. (2025) [16] emphasized the yield-protecting importance of suppressing Earias infestation, while Garg et al. (2025) [23] advocated integrating host response with broader pest management.
Based on standard heterosis and per se fruit yield the hybrid EC-305612 × EC-305672 ranked first with 45.53% heterosis with 293.25 g fruit yield. It was followed by the hybrid IC-10256A × EC-305672 (33.11% and 268.21 g), EC-305612 × IC-3769 (24.78% and 251.43 g), IC-4507 × IC-3769 (20.80% and 243.41 g), and EC-305612 × IC-4507 (15.98% and 233.70 g). Nanthakumar et al. (2021) [18] and Ranga et al. (2024) likewise stressed that standard heterosis should be considered together with per se performance and component-trait superiority.
We sincerely acknowledge to Assistant Breeder, Quality Seed Production Unit, Khanapur A Block, Vasantrao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani for providing facilities to conduct the experiment.
| Character | Replication MSS d.f. (1) | Treatment MSS d.f. (23) | Error MSS d.f. (23) | S.E. ± |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Days to 50% flowering | 0.083 | 31.869** | 0.387 | 0.440 |
| Plant height (cm) | 1.373 | 538.054** | 4.731 | 1.538 |
| Internodal length (cm) | 0.004 | 0.939** | 0.001 | 0.023 |
| Number of nodes per plant | 0.005 | 2.999** | 0.002 | 0.034 |
| Number of branches per plant | 0.001 | 0.544** | 0.001 | 0.028 |
| Number of ridges per fruit | 0.040 | 0.017** | 0.0269 | 0.116 |
| Fruit length (cm) | 0.046 | 8.676** | 0.018 | 0.095 |
| Fruit diameter | 0.001 | 0.042** | 0.0005 | 0.018 |
| Number of fruits per plant | 0.001 | 9.719** | 0.001 | 0.030 |
| Fruit weight (g) | 0.031 | 8.723** | 0.110 | 0.235 |
| Fruit yield per plant (g) | 0.693 | 2059.451** | 19.635 | 3.133 |
| Fruit and shoot borer severity (%) | 0.520 | 28.238** | 7.586 | 1.947 |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively
| Cross | Days to flowering | Plant height | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | |
| IC-10256A × EC-305612 | 1.14 | -8.25 ** | -1.11 | -8.25 ** | -4.30 ** | 18.69 ** | 1.17 | 12.28 ** | 24.70 ** | 6.38 ** |
| IC-10256A × EC-305672 | 17.86 ** | 11.24 ** | 10.00 ** | 2.06 | 6.45 ** | 52.98 ** | 37.70 ** | 34.58 ** | 49.46 ** | 27.51 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-4507 | 15.19 ** | 15.19 ** | 1.11 | -6.19 ** | -2.15 | 23.96 ** | 16.67 ** | 3.42 | 14.86 ** | -2.01 |
| IC-10256A × IC-3769 | 1.89 | 1.25 | -10.00 ** | -16.49 ** | -12.90 ** | -16.17 ** | -31.53 ** | -15.48 ** | -6.13 * | -19.92 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-7472 | 14.84 ** | 12.66 ** | -1.11 | -8.25 ** | -4.30 ** | 11.23 ** | 5.01 | -7.52 ** | 2.71 | -12.37 ** |
| EC-305612 × EC-305672 | 8.60 ** | 4.12 ** | 12.22 ** | 4.12 ** | 8.60 ** | 30.98 ** | 23.16 ** | 36.68 ** | 51.80 ** | 29.51 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 3.41 * | -6.19 ** | 1.11 | -6.19 ** | -2.15 | 12.25 ** | 0.96 | 12.04 ** | 24.43 ** | 6.16 * |
| EC-305612 × IC-3769 | 7.34 ** | -2.06 | 5.56 ** | -2.06 | 2.15 | 4.78 * | -0.51 | 22.80 ** | 36.39 ** | 16.36 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-7472 | -13.29 ** | -22.68 ** | -16.67 ** | -22.68 ** | -19.35 ** | -31.27 ** | -38.36 ** | -31.60 ** | -24.03 ** | -35.19 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-4507 | 7.14 ** | 1.12 | 0.00 | -7.22 ** | -3.23 * | -8.66 ** | -12.90 ** | -14.88 ** | -5.46 | -19.35 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-3769 | -6.51 ** | -11.24 ** | -12.22 ** | -18.56 ** | -15.05 ** | -28.47 ** | -35.92 ** | -20.90 ** | -12.15 ** | -25.06 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-7472 | -0.61 | -7.87 ** | -8.89 ** | -15.46 ** | -11.83 ** | 2.94 | -2.14 | -4.37 | 6.21 * | -9.39 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-3769 | -3.14 * | -3.75 * | -14.44 ** | -20.62 ** | -17.20 ** | -27.08 ** | -37.35 ** | -22.68 ** | -14.12 ** | -26.73 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-7472 | 0.65 | -1.27 | -13.33 ** | -19.59 ** | -16.13 ** | 1.06 | 0.73 | -10.71 ** | -0.83 | -15.40 ** |
| IC-3769 × IC-7472 | 16.67 ** | 13.75 ** | 1.11 | -6.19 ** | -2.15 | 3.33 | -11.47 ** | 9.27 ** | 21.36 ** | 3.53 |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively Table No. 2 Continued
| Cross | Internodal length | Number of nodes per plant | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | |
| IC-10256A × EC-305612 | -0.63 | -11.09 ** | -25.34 ** | -15.10 ** | -16.97 ** | 25.35 ** | 12.27 ** | 12.97 ** | 23.25 ** | 17.15 ** |
| IC-10256A × EC-305672 | -16.42 ** | -18.48 ** | -31.55 ** | -22.16 ** | -23.87 ** | 39.94 ** | 32.14 ** | 18.41 ** | 29.18 ** | 22.79 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-4507 | 14.91 ** | 8.42 ** | -8.97 ** | 3.53 ** | 1.25 | 9.25 ** | 3.51 ** | -7.89 ** | 0.49 | -4.48 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-3769 | -0.19 | -8.19 ** | -8.19 ** | 4.41 ** | 2.11 ** | -5.98 ** | -17.95 ** | -12.35 ** | -4.38 ** | -9.11 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-7472 | -21.39 ** | -26.52 ** | -29.05 ** | -19.31 ** | -21.09 ** | 6.77 ** | 1.51 ** | -10.34 ** | -2.19 ** | -7.03 ** |
| EC-305612 × EC-305672 | -2.54 ** | -10.80 ** | -28.79 ** | -19.02 ** | -20.81 ** | 29.65 ** | 22.55 ** | 23.32 ** | 34.53 ** | 27.88 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 42.93 ** | 35.07 ** | 0.60 | 14.41 ** | 11.89 ** | 11.73 ** | 5.27 ** | 5.93 ** | 15.56 ** | 9.85 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-3769 | -21.72 ** | -34.91 ** | -34.91 ** | -25.98 ** | -27.61 ** | 3.76 ** | 0.75 | 7.62 ** | 17.41 ** | 11.60 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-7472 | 26.31 ** | 6.52 ** | 2.84 ** | 16.96 ** | 14.38 ** | -2.93 ** | -8.86 ** | -8.29 ** | 0.05 | -4.90 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-4507 | 19.33 ** | 15.33 ** | -7.93 ** | 4.71 ** | 2.40 ** | 12.88 ** | 12.49 ** | 0.80 | 9.97 ** | 4.53 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-3769 | -7.57 ** | -16.90 ** | -16.90 ** | -5.49 ** | -7.57 ** | -9.94 ** | -17.20 ** | -11.55 ** | -3.50 ** | -8.28 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-7472 | -15.25 ** | -22.59 ** | -25.26 ** | -15.00 ** | -16.87 ** | 2.43 ** | 1.69 ** | -8.87 ** | -0.58 | -5.50 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-3769 | 10.67 ** | -3.45 ** | -3.45 ** | 9.80 ** | 7.38 ** | -11.25 ** | -18.66 ** | -13.11 ** | -5.20 ** | -9.89 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-7472 | -2.92 ** | -14.02 ** | -16.98 ** | -5.59 ** | -7.67 ** | -0.73 | -1.10 * | -11.99 ** | -3.99 ** | -8.74 ** |
| IC-3769 × IC-7472 | -11.49 ** | -13.02 ** | -13.02 ** | -1.08 | -3.26 ** | -2.63 ** | -11.06 ** | -4.99 ** | 3.65 ** | -1.48 ** |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively Table No. 2 Continued
| Cross | Number of branches per plant | Number of ridges | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | |
| IC-10256A × EC-305612 | 15.90 ** | 5.20 ** | 8.45 ** | 12.47 ** | 10.69 ** | 2.91 | 1.92 | 3.92 | 3.92 | 3.92 |
| IC-10256A × EC-305672 | 26.11 ** | 16.95 ** | 15.00 ** | 19.26 ** | 17.38 ** | 3.92 | 1.92 | 3.92 | 3.92 | 3.92 |
| IC-10256A × IC-4507 | 17.91 ** | 14.75 ** | 1.90 * | 5.68 ** | 4.01 ** | 0.97 | 0.00 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 |
| IC-10256A × IC-3769 | -22.43 ** | -32.06 ** | -24.05 ** | -21.23 ** | -22.48 ** | 2.91 | 1.92 | 3.92 | 3.92 | 3.92 |
| IC-10256A × IC-7472 | 10.98 ** | 8.07 ** | -9.17 ** | -5.80 ** | -7.29 ** | -0.97 | -1.92 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| EC-305612 × EC-305672 | 19.74 ** | 16.97 ** | 20.60 ** | 25.06 ** | 23.09 ** | 0.99 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 9.06 ** | 1.50 | 4.64 ** | 8.52 ** | 6.80 ** | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| EC-305612 × IC-3769 | 3.71 ** | -0.32 | 11.43 ** | 15.56 ** | 13.73 ** | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| EC-305612 × IC-7472 | -19.35 ** | -28.52 ** | -26.31 ** | -23.58 ** | -24.79 ** | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 |
| EC-305672 × IC-4507 | 6.74 ** | 1.57 | -0.12 | 3.58 ** | 1.94 * | 0.99 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| EC-305672 × IC-3769 | -15.81 ** | -20.87 ** | -11.55 ** | -8.27 ** | -9.72 ** | 6.93* | 5.88 | 5.88 | 5.88 | 5.88 |
| EC-305672 × IC-7472 | 7.83 ** | -2.42 * | -4.05 ** | -0.49 | -2.07 * | 0.99 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| IC-4507 × IC-3769 | -17.03 ** | -25.56 ** | -16.79 ** | -13.70 ** | -15.07 ** | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
| IC-4507 × IC-7472 | 2.61 ** | -2.68 * | -13.57 ** | -10.37 ** | -11.79 ** | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 |
| IC-3769 × IC-7472 | 7.96 ** | -7.56 ** | 3.33 ** | 7.16 ** | 5.47 ** | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 | 1.96 |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively Table No. 2 Continued
Sawani in okra for different traits
| Cross | Fruit length | Fruit diameter | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | |
| IC-10256A × EC-305612 | 13.56 ** | 4.48 ** | 8.02 ** | 0.74 | -3.58 ** | 6.69 ** | 5.16 ** | 7.94 ** | 9.88 ** | 6.07 ** |
| IC-10256A × EC-305672 | 18.68 ** | 11.38 ** | 10.30 ** | 2.87 ** | -1.54 | 11.87 ** | 11.21 ** | 10.88 ** | 12.87 ** | 8.96 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-4507 | 36.43 ** | 29.62 ** | 12.59 ** | 5.00 ** | 0.49 | 9.15 ** | 3.83 * | 3.53 * | 5.39 ** | 1.73 |
| IC-10256A × IC-3769 | 26.32 ** | 13.78 ** | 23.31 ** | 15.00 ** | 10.06 ** | -10.27 ** | -14.25 ** | -6.18 ** | -4.49 ** | -7.80 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-7472 | 39.04 ** | 34.83 ** | 17.12 ** | 9.22 ** | 4.54 ** | 7.59 ** | 0.29 | 0.00 | 1.80 | -1.73 |
| EC-305612 × EC-305672 | 16.26 ** | 13.81 ** | 17.67 ** | 9.74 ** | 5.03 ** | 13.16 ** | 10.89 ** | 13.82 ** | 15.87 ** | 11.85 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 16.43 ** | 2.24 * | 5.71 ** | -1.42 | -5.65 ** | 6.26 ** | -0.29 | 2.35 | 4.19 ** | 0.58 |
| EC-305612 × IC-3769 | 6.66 ** | 4.21 ** | 12.93 ** | 5.32 ** | 0.80 | 3.47 ** | 0.27 | 9.71 ** | 11.68 ** | 7.80 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-7472 | -1.20 | -11.61 ** | -8.61 ** | -14.77 ** | -18.43 ** | 0.62 | -7.45 ** | -5.00 ** | -3.29 * | -6.65 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-4507 | 29.29 ** | 15.68 ** | 14.56 ** | 6.84 ** | 2.25 * | -2.96 * | -7.16 ** | -8.53 ** | -6.89 ** | -10.12 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-3769 | -23.14 ** | -26.45 ** | -20.30 ** | -25.67 ** | -28.86 ** | -17.68 ** | -21.77 ** | -14.41 ** | -12.87 ** | -15.90 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-7472 | 14.74 ** | 4.64 ** | 3.63 ** | -3.35 ** | -7.50 ** | 1.91 | -4.48 ** | -5.88 ** | -4.19 ** | -7.51 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-3769 | -4.50 ** | -17.80 ** | -10.93 ** | -16.93 ** | -20.49 ** | -15.63 ** | -23.12 ** | -15.88 ** | -14.37 ** | -17.34 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-7472 | -14.91 ** | -16.69 ** | -32.02 ** | -36.60 ** | -39.32 ** | -3.51 * | -5.56 ** | -15.00 ** | -13.47 ** | -16.47 ** |
| IC-3769 × IC-7472 | 10.59 ** | -3.06 ** | 5.05 ** | -2.03 * | -6.23 ** | 5.26 ** | -5.91 ** | 2.94 | 4.79 ** | 1.16 |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively Table No. 2 Continued
| Cross | Number of fruits per plant | Fruit weight | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | |
| IC-10256A × EC-305612 | 20.21 ** | 8.17 ** | 12.81 ** | 17.14 ** | 12.48 ** | 18.89 ** | 1.97 | 11.54 ** | 18.28 ** | 8.21 ** |
| IC-10256A × EC-305672 | 34.80 ** | 24.66 ** | 22.37 ** | 27.07 ** | 22.01 ** | 36.15 ** | 22.35 ** | 20.07 ** | 27.33 ** | 16.48 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-4507 | 20.33 ** | 19.08 ** | 1.41 ** | 5.31 ** | 1.11 ** | 25.65 ** | 19.57 ** | 3.58 | 9.84 ** | 0.49 |
| IC-10256A × IC-3769 | -13.65 ** | -24.46 ** | -15.95 ** | -12.72 ** | -16.20 ** | 14.25 ** | 9.39 ** | -6.45 * | -0.80 | -9.25 ** |
| IC-10256A × IC-7472 | 5.25 ** | 4.24 ** | -11.37 ** | -7.96 ** | -11.63 ** | 18.44 ** | 15.50 ** | -4.91 | 0.84 | -7.75 ** |
| EC-305612 × EC-305672 | 24.77 ** | 21.11 ** | 26.30 ** | 31.16 ** | 25.93 ** | 24.46 ** | 18.05 ** | 29.14 ** | 36.94 ** | 25.28 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 4.43 ** | -5.15 ** | -1.08 ** | 2.72 ** | -1.37 ** | 9.97 ** | -1.47 | 7.78 ** | 14.29 ** | 4.55 |
| EC-305612 × IC-3769 | 4.54 ** | 1.27 ** | 12.68 ** | 17.01 ** | 12.34 ** | 14.53 ** | 2.03 | 11.61 ** | 18.36 ** | 8.28 ** |
| EC-305612 × IC-7472 | -25.05 ** | -31.97 ** | -29.05 ** | -26.33 ** | -29.26 ** | -7.76 ** | -19.17 ** | -11.58 ** | -6.23 * | -14.22 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-4507 | 9.92 ** | 2.64 ** | 0.75 * | 4.63 ** | 0.46 | 10.92 ** | 4.42 | 2.47 | 8.67 ** | -0.59 |
| EC-305672 × IC-3769 | -29.09 ** | -33.26 ** | -25.75 ** | -22.89 ** | -25.96 ** | -6.48 * | -12.49 ** | -14.12 ** | -8.93 ** | -16.69 ** |
| EC-305672 × IC-7472 | 2.59 ** | -4.27 ** | -6.03 ** | -2.41 ** | -6.30 ** | 10.15 ** | 1.28 | -0.61 | 5.40 | -3.58 |
| IC-4507 × IC-3769 | -15.82 ** | -25.70 ** | -17.33 ** | -14.15 ** | -17.57 ** | 41.70 ** | 40.79 ** | 21.97 ** | 29.34 ** | 18.32 ** |
| IC-4507 × IC-7472 | -6.89 ** | -6.96 ** | -20.77 ** | -17.72 ** | -21.00 ** | 59.65 ** | 55.69 ** | 34.87 ** | 43.03 ** | 30.84 ** |
| IC-3769 × IC-7472 | 6.42 ** | -6.12 ** | 4.45 ** | 8.47 ** | 4.15 ** | 2.93 | 1.01 | -13.62 ** | -8.40 ** | -16.20 ** |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively Table No. 2 Continued
| Cross | Fruit yield per plant | Shoot borer severity | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | Average heterosis | Heterobeltiosis | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | |
| IC-10256A × EC-305612 | 15.29 ** | -3.43 | 11.05 ** | 15.43 ** | 6.60 ** | -6.67 | 133.33 | -22.22 | -30.00 | -12.50 |
| IC-10256A × EC-305672 | 35.48 ** | 14.97 ** | 28.06 ** | 33.11 ** | 22.92 ** | -47.37* | -28.57 | -44.44 | -50.00* | -37.50 |
| IC-10256A × IC-4507 | 29.83 ** | 22.53 ** | 7.21 ** | 11.44 ** | 2.91 | -41.67* | -41.67* | -22.22 | -30.00 | -12.50 |
| IC-10256A × IC-3769 | -6.54 ** | -22.75 ** | -8.15 ** | -4.53 | -11.84 ** | -5.26 | 28.57 | 0.00 | -10.00 | 12.50 |
| IC-10256A × IC-7472 | 20.44 ** | 17.18 ** | -3.80 | 0.00 | -7.65 ** | -4.35 | 0.00 | 22.22 | 10.00 | 37.50 |
| EC-305612 × EC-305672 | 23.70 ** | 21.75 ** | 40.01 ** | 45.53 ** | 34.40 ** | 0.00 | 66.67 | -44.44 | -50.00* | -37.50 |
| EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 10.20 ** | -2.97 | 11.58 ** | 15.98 ** | 7.10 ** | 6.67 | 166.67* | -11.11 | -20.00 | 0.00 |
| EC-305612 × IC-3769 | 2.65 | 0.97 | 20.05 ** | 24.78 ** | 15.23 ** | -20.00 | 33.33 | -55.56* | -60.00* | -50.00 |
| EC-305612 × IC-7472 | -9.23 ** | -22.22 ** | -10.55 ** | -7.02 ** | -14.14 ** | 57.14* | 266.67** | 22.22 | 10.00 | 37.50 |
| EC-305672 × IC-4507 | 5.60 ** | -5.73 ** | 5.00 * | 9.14 ** | 0.79 | 5.26 | 42.86 | 11.11 | 0.00 | 25.00 |
| EC-305672 × IC-3769 | -25.24 ** | -27.60 ** | -13.92 ** | -10.53 ** | -17.38 ** | 85.71** | 85.71* | 44.44 | 30.00 | 62.50* |
| EC-305672 × IC-7472 | -1.59 | -14.53 ** | -4.80 * | -1.04 | -8.62 ** | 11.11 | 42.86 | 11.11 | 0.00 | 25.00 |
| IC-4507 × IC-3769 | 12.62 ** | -2.25 | 16.22 ** | 20.80 ** | 11.56 ** | -68.42** | -57.14 | -66.67* | -70.00** | -62.50* |
| IC-4507 × IC-7472 | 4.64 | 1.42 | -11.27 ** | -7.76 ** | -14.82 ** | 13.04 | 18.18 | 44.44 | 30.00 | 62.50* |
| IC-3769 × IC-7472 | 8.77 ** | -8.06 ** | 9.31 ** | 13.63 ** | 4.93 * | -22.22 | 0.00 | -22.22 | -30.00 | -12.50 |
*, ** Significant at 5% and 1% respectively
| Sr. No. | Cross combination | Heterosis % | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MP | BP | Parbhani Kranti | Radhika | Pusa Sawani | ||
| 1 | EC-305612 × EC-305672 | 23.70 ** | 21.75 ** | 40.01 ** | 45.53 ** | 34.40 ** |
| 2 | IC-10256A × EC-305672 | 35.48 ** | 14.97 ** | 28.06 ** | 33.11 ** | 22.92 ** |
| 3 | EC-305612 × IC-3769 | 2.65 | 0.97 | 20.05 ** | 24.78 ** | 15.23 ** |
| 4 | IC-4507 × IC-3769 | 12.62 ** | -2.25 | 16.22 ** | 20.80 ** | 11.56 ** |
| 5 | EC-305612 × IC-4507 | 10.20 ** | -2.97 | 11.58 ** | 15.98 ** | 7.10 ** |

Average heterosis (MP), heterobeltiosis (BP) and standard heterosis over Parbhani Kranti, Radhika and Pusa Sawani
The hybrids PA 987 X PA 837, PA 950 X AKA 2016-3 and PA 987 X PA 402 were found to be highly heterotic for seed cotton yield whereas, the hybrids PA 972 X PA 785 and PA 987 X PA 402 were found highly heterotic for fibre quality traits. Hence these hybrids could be further tested at multilocations and seasons before release as commercial hybrid for commercial cultivation.